Promoting Eugenics in the Los Angeles Times
Hogue started writing for the Times in 1921–1922, authoring a six-part series on his travels in Mexico along the “old Aztec trail.” Hogue’s descriptions of “primitive folk in Mexico’s mountains” foreshadowed the disdain expressed one decade later in “Social Eugenics.” In his view, Mexican were backwards in evolutionary terms and therefore “unfit” for arrival or assimilation in California. He applied this biased lens to non-white groups again and again in his writing.
Although it’s not clear what prompted Hogue to launch “Social Eugenics” in 1935, it coincided with the height of California’s eugenics movement, when organizations such as the Human Betterment Foundation, the Southern California Branch of the American Eugenics Society, and the Eugenics Society of Northern California were in full swing, disseminating racist and ableist ideas about the biological inferiority of immigrants, people of color, and people with disabilities. Hogue was in regular contact with these organizations and leading eugenicists. He expressed deep anxiety about the influx and propagation of “unfit” people in the state, as announced in the headline for his inaugural article “Shall the Unfit Weaken the Race?” For Hogue the “unfit” were a biological menace that threatened to poison the “fit” and preferred – understood as white middle-class – demographic of the state.
Hogue was not shy about voicing support for Nazi Germany and its plan to eradicate the reproduction of “offspring with hereditary diseases.” As he wrote in 1939,
Hogue touted California’s sterilization law, passed in 1909, and was proud that Germany used it as a model for its 1933 law. Hogue followed fascist developments and eugenic programs in Italy, Japan, and many other countries, hoping that passage of policies to eliminate “defective genes” and sanitize the “bloodstream” would gain greater traction across the globe.Hitler, with the support of the German people is an exponent of sterilization of the unfit among his own people. He seeks large families where the bloodstream is pure, and no children where there is an infected blood stream.
At the same time, Hogue was intensely focused on eugenics in California. He was particularly connected to the Human Betterment Foundation, founded by citrus magnate Ezra Gosney in 1928, to investigate and advocate for eugenic sterilization in California. Indeed, one of the foundation’s most steadfast members was Paul Popenoe, who traveled to state institutions in the late 1920s to gather data on sterilization practices. In the clubby fraternal world of California eugenicists, Gosney used his connections to ensure that Popenoe had full access to state homes and hospitals like Sonoma and Napa. Historians today reviewing the foundation’s papers can easily see that the data was purposefully selected and twisted to extol the benefits of sterilization, a perspective captured in numerous articles resulting from this “research.” An influential book, Sterilization for Human Betterment: A Summary of Results of 6,000 Operations in California, 1909–1929, was published in 1929 and became a reference for eugenicists in and beyond the United States.
Hogue praised the mission of the Human Betterment Foundation and endorsed its attempt in 1939 to expand the sterilization law to encompass individuals deemed “unfit” who were not housed in state institutions, a change that he declared would be “cheaper for the state” and lessen the burden of “public charges.” Hogue claimed he had received hundreds of letters supporting this change. Ultimately, no such change occurred. Even so, California sterilized over 20,000 people from 1909 to 1979 while its law was on the books, one-third of all the procedures carried out nation-wide during the twentieth century.
Hogue’s sudden death in 1941 put an end to “Social Eugenics,” but by then his message had been conveyed in about 200 articles, doubtlessly shaping opinions in Los Angeles. His series “Social Eugenics” was an important piece of the eugenic puzzle in California, helping to legitimate eugenics as science and progress during the first half of the twentieth century.
This page has paths:
- Disability, Medicine, and Expertise Gianna May Sanchez
- California Jacqueline D. Wernimont