Eugenic States: A Contextual Archive

California’s Sterilization Law and the Women Who Challenged It

California’s sterilization law is striking for many reasons, first and foremost that it remained on the books without interruption for seven decades, until its repeal in 1979. In other states, laws were overturned, repealed, and held in legal abeyance for years, because they were judged to be “cruel and unusual punishment” or didn’t allow sufficient avenues for appeal. But that was not the case in California.

Nevertheless, the law did not go uncontested. Families and patients refused to consent to sterilization and patients who escaped institutions to avoid such reproductive fate. Moreover, there were several prominent legal cases that challenged California’s sterilization law. The one that received the most press at the time was the case of Ann Cooper Hewitt, an heiress who was sterilized at her mother’s behest and description of her daughter as “feebleminded.” Although this procedure didn’t occur in a state institution, it raised awareness of the fraught nature of forced sterilization in California.

Two other cases capture the dynamics of California’s sterilization program even more vividly. Both cases involved Mexican American women who rejected state control of their or their family member’s reproductive freedom.

In February 1930, Concepcion Ruiz, a 16-year-old Mexican American girl, was arrested and tried in California Juvenile Court on charges of sexual delinquency. Legal officers brought the young woman before Superior Court Judge Robert H. Scott because she ran away with a boyfriend and was allegedly “subnormal.” In the eyes of California probation officers, judges, and medical superintendents, Ruiz’s interest in boys, her decision to run away, and her lower-than-average IQ score were enough evidence to declare her “mentally deficient.” Judge Scott sent Concepcion to Sonoma and recommended her for sterilization. After several months of confinement, sterilized Ruiz despite her vocal protest and adamant refusal for consent. By November, Ruiz had gained her freedom and with the help of her sister, Sylvia, filed a lawsuit against Judge Scott, Sonoma’s medical superintendent, and the probation officers who conspired to have her committed and rendered infertile.

In the lawsuit, Concepcion highlighted the numerous ways in which legal and institutional authorities violated her constitutional rights. She was not informed of her right to obtain legal counsel, was required to testify against herself, and was summarily forced to undergo an irreversible surgery without the benefit of due process. Her life would be forever changed, and for that she demanded $150,000 in damages. Unfortunately, the outcome of Ruiz’s case is unknown, but the decision was likely not in favor of Ruiz.

Nine years later, Sara Rosas Garcia sued the state of California because state authorities recommended her nineteen-year-old daughter Andrea Garcia for eugenic sterilization. At the time Andrea was a ward of the Los Angeles Juvenile Court, which had determined that her “feebleminded” condition warranted institutionalization and reproductive surgery. Although no longer her child’s legal guardian, Sara nevertheless went to great efforts to forestall Andrea’s sterilization. In doing so Sara became the only person to ever challenge the constitutionality of California’s eugenic sterilization statute during the nine decades it was in place.

The sparse historical records related to Andrea Garcia indicate that juvenile authorities designated her a ward of the state because of school truancy and sexual promiscuity. These offenses, coupled with a low I.Q. score of 46 (which ranked her in the “high imbecile grade”), prompted the juvenile court to commit her to Pacific Colony, a hospital for the “feebleminded” in Pomona that had opened in the late 1920s.

Eleven days after her daughter’s court-ordered commitment, Sara sued the state of California, challenging the constitutionality of the sterilization statute. Through the Mexican consulate Sara found David C. Marcus, who provided her with pro bono legal counsel. A Jewish attorney trained at the University of Southern California, Marcus dedicated himself to civil rights causes, most involving Latinas/os. In the 1940s Marcus was lead counsel on cases that contested racial housing covenants, restrictions from public and recreational facilities, and school segregation. He is best known for litigating Mendez v. Westminster (1947), which successfully challenged racial segregation in California’s public school system. Arguing many cases for his Latina/o clients against the global backdrop of Nazism’s rise, Marcus was acutely aware of the prevalence and reach of eugenic ideas in southern California. In Mendez, for example, he reproached a school district superintendent for exhibiting “an attitude of racial superiority such as that of Hitler” toward Latina/o students.

Because of this experience, Andrea’s court case must have struck a chord. She had been labeled a “mentally deficient, sex delinquent girl” based on a low I.Q. score, an assessment that her parents and siblings were similarly “subnormal” and “deficient,” and a description of her home as “unfit.” Like many Mexican-origin people who became caught in the net of state welfare authorities, Andrea and her entire family were painted with a eugenic brush of deficiency and delinquency.

In the petition filed with the Second District Court of Appeal in Los Angeles, Marcus argued that California’s sterilization law, which gave authorities the power to perform reproductive surgeries on persons “afflicted with hereditary insanity or incurable chronic mania or dementia,” was unconstitutional. He charged that it contradicted the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution by violating the “fundamental and inalienable right of said minor, Andrea Garcia, to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” In addition, it violated the equal protection and due process clauses of both the federal and California constitutions. Particularly egregious, the law did not allow for any hearing, notice, or appeal, and granted unchecked power to administrative authorities.

A three-judge panel decided against Sara Rosas Garcia. While two judges upheld the law without comment, the remaining judge simultaneously issued a fierce dissent, concurring with the petition and underscoring that the lack of an appeal process for inmates was a “probable violation of the due process clause of the federal Constitution.”

Records are equivocal on whether Sara’s efforts spared Andrea from the procedure. Sara apparently signed Andrea’s consent form for reproductive surgery in 1941, with two individuals signing as witnesses, one from the Los Angeles Police Department and another from the Los Angeles City Schools. Yet on the index card used by state superintendents to record both the date of the sterilization recommendation and the date of the actual operation, the latter is missing. Perhaps news of the lawsuit gave the medical superintendent pause and shielded Andrea from surgery, or perhaps the date simply was not recorded because of a clerical lapse.

Whatever the outcome, Pacific Colony eventually released Andrea. She did not have any children, although she did marry in 1959. By that time some members of the Rosas Garcia family had moved out of their Boyle Heights home to San Luis Obispo County in the north. Sara remarried and lived in the agricultural town of Nipomo. She died in 1987, and Andrea died in 2008. Today they are buried, along with three of Andrea’s siblings and her stepfather, in Santa Maria Cemetery.

Despite the overwhelming power of legal officials, physicians, and superintendents to diagnose and decide the reproductive future of individuals declared “defective” or “unfit,” stories of resistance, like Ruiz’s and Rosas Garcia’s, abound. Often, it was Latina/o parents and patients who fought the system. Some Latinos brought legal claims against institutional authorities. Parents and guardians often refused to sign consent forms. Others wrote letters to community leaders, priests and even the Mexican Consulate for help in preventing sterilizations. Latina/os resisted in surgery rooms and even escaped from institutions. They asserted claims to civil rights in the face of eugenic efforts to classify them as unworthy and unfit.

This page has paths:

  1. Courts and the Law Gianna May Sanchez
  2. California Jacqueline D. Wernimont

This page references: