Eugenic States: A Contextual Archive

Sexuality and Sterilization in North Carolina

Describing a patient as sexually uncontrollable became petitioners’ most successful strategy for convincing Eugenics Board members of the necessity of sterilization. The sterilization petitions for one woman, Ella, demonstrate this growing emphasis that social workers placed on clients’ sexuality in sterilization petitions. In 1964, the welfare department in Bladen county filed a petition for fourteen-year-old Ella. The petition noted that she had been born out of wedlock, her mother had been murdered, and she was living with her grandmother and aunt who were said to be concerned about her. The petition stated:

Ella has been a problem in the school and community but is now said to behave in a more acceptable fashion. She attends the sixth grade in school but is unable to learn, profiting only from the companionship of her class mates. The grandmother wants sterilization for Ella because she feels that this will give protection against unwanted pregnancies since there are ample opportunities for sexual relationships despite supervision.

However, given that Ella was only fourteen, lived in a supervised environment, and seemed to show no interest in sex,  board members denied the petition. Four months later, the received a second petition for Ella’s sterilization that emphasized her sexuality and her inability to support herself financially. Now fifteen years of age, the petition noted that Ella was showing increased interest in boys. Since she was unable to “take care of herself,“ had “never been employable,” and could not support herself financially, her grandmother and the petitioning social worker sought sterilization as a “protection for her since she is quite interested in boys and cannot constantly be watched.” In spite of these combined economic and sexual concerns, the Eugenics Board again denied the petition. It seems most likely that the board members remained unconvinced of Ella's interest in sex.

A third petition filed the following year left no doubt about Ella’s status as both a sexual aggressor and a sexual victim. It noted:

[Ella] not only wanders about causing trouble. She is fully developed physically and has begun to show a decided interest in boys. She often sneaks out of the house unnoticed and goes about the neighborhood looking for boys. The grandmother states that if she is left alone for even a short period of time it is necessary to run the boys away from her. The grandmother and aunt feel that it is only a matter of time before she becomes pregnant. Both feel that sterilization is in the best interest of this retarded child who cannot care for her own needs let alone those of another person.

This time board members approved the petition.

There is a lot to unpack about Ella‘s case. There are inconsistencies between petitions, including how her indicated race changed from the second to third petition from Black to white. The social worker based her “diagnosis” on a test she took two years prior at the start of these petitions, when she was twelve years old. Further testing was not indicated in her petition, suggesting that the Eugenics Board relied solely on an old exam and the social workers’ and grandmother’s evaluation of Ella’s capability to determine if she should be sterilized or not. Rather than an error, this lack of additional testing indicates how much weight the Eugenics Board placed on perceived sexual deviancy and controlling “feebleminded” bodies. The third petition mentioned that Ella was “fully developed,” which emphasized her status of a woman of child-bearing age.

Ella’s numerous petitions demonstrate that it was not only health and social work professionals but also parents and other relatives who wished for the sterilization of teenage children. Some guardians, like Ella’s grandmother and aunt, worried that sterilization candidates would never be able to take care of themselves or their children, and, fearing the burden of having to care for additional family members, they sought sterilization to prevent their charges from becoming pregnant. Rather than blame those that could potentially assault Ella or examine other factors that could have influenced her supposed “delinquency,” her grandmother supported sterilization as the best option for her. Moreover, the sterilization of sexually active daughters could protect the family's reputation and avoid shameful out-of-wedlock pregnancies. Like Ella’s grandmother, some parents were only too glad when the Department of Public Welfare stepped into the picture. In another case, all the relatives of eighteen-year-old Martha found her “out of control” and were unwilling to take her in. To both her aunts and her mother, sterilization seemed a good solution. While some parents were careful to weigh all their options and consult their children when considering the procedure, others looked to sterilization more for their own convenience and gave little thought to the implications that the surgery had for their children’s futures.

This page has paths:

  1. Sexuality, Reproduction, and the Body Gianna May Sanchez
  2. North Carolina Jacqueline D. Wernimont